Beverage brands today sit at the intersection of shifting consumer values, cultural fragmentation and accelerated competition. Social media amplifies every niche, making it easier for once-obscure drinks to go viral overnight. At the same time, generational divides in how people approach alcohol—from Gen-Z’s preference for low- or no-ABV options to Millennials’ focus on premium experiences—are reshaping the category.
For brand and marketing leaders, the challenge isn’t just gaining attention—it’s sustaining loyalty in a world where everyone can be in the know all at once. Cult-worthy brands offer a roadmap. They thrive by leaning into polarization, building lore that spreads organically and creating rituals that make consumers feel like insiders. In a market where sameness dominates and algorithms drive discovery, these are the qualities that separate brands with staying power from those that disappear as fast as a TikTok trend.
Defining Cult-Worthy
A cult brand isn’t simply well liked—it’s polarizing. Followers are ride or die, fiercely loyal, while detractors can’t stand it. That edge is what sparks conversation and keeps the brand alive in culture. Cult brands not designed to appeal to everyone—and mass-market companies who aspire to cult status need to be comfortable with that.
1. Anchor in Familiarity, Then Break Away
Successful beverage brands use familiar category cues to establish credibility—but stop short of blending into the sea of sameness. Light beer leans on blue and silver. Whiskey shows up in serif fonts, batch numbers and craft paper. Vodka bottles often stand tall with poppy colors and sans serif type. Anchors matter, but distinctiveness matters more.
Jeppson’s Malört shows how a brand can build cult status by embracing what makes it divisive. Known for its intense bitterness, comparisons to gasoline or grapefruit pith, and the infamous “Malört face” of disgust, it’s widely considered undrinkable. Yet that extremity has become its badge of honor. For some, enduring a shot is a rite of passage, a moment of shared suffering that turns into social bonding. This experience makes it more than a beverage—it’s a story to be told, and that story drives the fandom.
2. Craft a True Reason to Believe
Overused claims like “world’s finest” don’t cut it. A cult-worthy brand offers proof that feels authentic and singular. Whether it’s a founder’s story, an unconventional brewing process, or a bold new format, brands must dig deeper for a reason to believe that belongs only to them. Social media has raised the stakes—now everyone can be in the know instantly. What’s shared has to feel insider-worthy, not generic.
3. Embrace Cultural Relevance and Ritual
Cult brands don’t just sell products; they sell belonging. BuzzBallz became a Gen-Z staple because it leaned into unhinged humor, turning into a badge of “look what I’m drinking.” The Spaghett—a Miller High Life bottle spiked with Aperol and lemon juice—was celebrated as the drink of the summer. Its appeal lies in being simple, refreshing and a little irreverent: no shaker, no stemware, just a cheap beer turned into something slyly sophisticated. Both examples show how cult drinks thrive on shared rituals that feel accessible yet insider.
4. Preserve and Evolve the Lore
Every cult brand wrestles with staying relevant without losing what made it special. Integrity comes from knowing what to protect and what to evolve. Cutwater has stayed true to its mission of making bar-quality cocktails more accessible, presenting polished content that highlights quality, flavor and occasions to drink. At the same time, its high-ABV cans have fueled fan-driven lore online, sparking imaginative collabs like the Hulk (a Cutwater x Hennessy mashup) that consumers in the comments wish were real. By letting fans be fanatics—extending the lore through off-the-wall collab ideas and at-home cocktail riffs—Cutwater amplifies its cultural reach while keeping its core promise intact.
5. Narrow the Focus, Deepen the Following
Cult-worthy brands succeed because they know their consumer with precision. The beverage aisle forces choice—30 seltzers in a case make every brand define its lane. Compare that to categories with only a handful of options, where brands often stretch too broad. Even mass players gain power by thinking niche: clearly define the design target, understand habits and practices and build for a community rather than the masses.
The Path to Cult Status
Cult-worthy brands aren’t created overnight. They emerge through bold choices, consistent storytelling, and the willingness to polarize. In a fragmented, always-on world, the brands that lean into distinctiveness, culture and ritual—while preserving the lore that makes them unique—earn a fanatic following that drives growth.
Achieving that kind of status takes discipline across every touchpoint: strategy that defines where to play and how to win, design systems that balance category credibility with cultural distinction and packaging that acts as both anchor and amplifier on shelf and in social feeds. These are the levers that determine whether a brand fades into sameness or builds the kind of loyalty that feels unshakable.
ABOUT LPK
LPK is a modern brand consultancy that applies insightful strategy and beautiful creativity to harness change—making momentum that grows brands and businesses.
